Sierra Club Home Page   Environmental Update   My Backyard
chapter button
Explore, enjoy and protect the planet
Click here to visit the Member Center.         
Search
Take Action
Get Outdoors
Join or Give
Inside Sierra Club
Press Room
Politics & Issues
Sierra Magazine
Sierra Club Books
Apparel and Other Merchandise
Contact Us

Join the Sierra ClubWhy become a member? Explore, Enjoy and Protect
Backtrack
Legislative Tracker Main
In This Section
Gasoline for America's Security Act of 2005
America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act
Owyhee Initiative Implementation Act
White Pine County Conservation, Recreation and Development Act
The Eastern Sierra Rural Heritage and Economic Enhancement Act
Northern California Coastal Wild Heritage Wilderness Act
The National Oceans Preservation Act
A bill to designate a portion of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge as Wilderness
The Eastern Sierra Rural Heritage and Economic Enhancement Act
Mount Hood Stewardship Legacy Act
Threatened & Endangered Species Recovery Act
Central Idaho Economic Development and Recreation Act
Northern California Coastal Wild Heritage Wilderness Act
America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act
Northern Rockies Ecosystem Protection Act
Central Idaho Economic Development and Recreation Act
The Clean Water Authority Restoration Act
Great Lakes Regional Collaboration Implementation Act
Great Lakes Regional Collaboration Implementation Act
The Clean Water Authority Restoration Act
Exempt Factory Farms from Toxics Reporting and Liability
Exempt Factory Farms from Toxics Reporting and Liability
National Uniformity for Food Act of 2005
Fuel Economy Reform Act
Washington County Growth and Conservation Act
Washington County Growth and Conservation Act
Boehlert-Markey Fuel Efficiency Bill
Responsible Education About Life (REAL) Act
Prevention First Act
Focus on Family Health Worldwide Act
GROWTH (Global Resources and Opportunities for Women to Thrive) Act
Global Democracy Promotion Act
Global Poverty Act
Natural Gas Price Reduction Act of 2005
Judicial Nomination of Samuel Alito to the Supreme Court of the United States
Ken Saro-Wiwa Resolution
Virginia Ridge and Valley Wilderness and National Scenic Areas Act
Lewis and Clark Mount Hood Wilderness Act of 2006
The New England Wilderness Act
Roadless Area Conservation Act
The Vermont Wilderness Act
New Hampshire Wilderness Act
California Wild Heritage Act
Forest Emergency Recovery and Research Act (Walden Salvage Logging)
National Forest Roadless Area Conservation Act
National Forest Protection and Restoration Act
Virginia Ridge and Valley Wilderness and National Scenic Areas Act
Gulf of Mexico Energy Security Act of 2006
Global Warming Pollution Reduction Act
Gulf Coast Protection Act
COAST Anti-Drilling Act
California Ocean and Coastal Protection Act
Reliable and Affordable Natural Gas Energy Reform Act of 2006
Domenici Outer Continental Shelf Bill to Allow Drilling in Gulf of Mexico
Martinez-Nelson Outer Continental Shelf Bill to Protect Florida Coasts
Safe Climate Act of 2006
Davis Outer Continental Shelf Bill to Protect Florida Coasts
California Ocean and Coastal Protection Act
Deep Ocean Energy Resources Act of 2006
Outer Continental Shelf Natural Gas Relief Act
Inhofe Clean Air Attainment Enforcement Act
Clean Power Act
EPA Nomination of William Wehrum
Clean Smokestacks Act
 
Other Sessions
2008 Congressional Legislation
2007 Congressional Legislation
2005 Congressional Legislation

5 Forests:
Forest Emergency Recovery and Research Act (Walden Salvage Logging)

Our Position: oppose
Bill Number: HR4200
Sponsor: Greg Walden (R-WA)
Legislative Session: 2006

Rep. Greg Walden (R-OR) is working hard in his campaign to reduce environmental protections and make it easier for the US Forest Service to push salvage logging. Despite the fact that 40% of the overall timber volume from National Forests is now coming from post-disturbance salvage logging, Walden’s bill, the Forest Emergency Research and Recovery Act (HR 4200), would fast track destructive logging projects in National Forests impacted by natural disturbances such as fires, droughts, or windstorms. This destructive logging proposal would remove basic protections for clean water and wildlife habitat by cutting meaningful environmental review and excluding the public from the decision making processes. Their plan is a misguided attempt to manufacture a "crisis" where there isn't one and promote the Bush administration’s agenda of increasing subsidized commercial logging on our National Forests. Contrary to the Bush administration and Walden’s insistence, there is no ecological emergency to log National Forests after normal natural events.

Status

August 2006:  Hearings on this bill were held in the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry Subcommittee on Forestry, Conservation, and Rural Revitalization.

May 17, 2006: This bill passed in the House.  It was then passed on to the Senate.

 February 2006: Representative Walden held a field hearing in his district town of Medford, Oregon on Friday, February 24th, and the House Resources Committee considered the legislation on March 15th.  However, the Committee did not finish debating and voting on amendments and was forced to adjourn without completing the markup or passing the bill out of committee.  No continuing date has been scheduled, but is expected by the end of March of the beginning of April.

Action Needed

Please take a moment to call your Congressional Representative and urge them to oppose HR 4200, the “Forest Emergency Research and Recovery Act.” You can reach your Representative through the Capitol Hill switchboard at (202) 224-3121.

Contact

Sean Cosgrove
Senior Washington Representative
National Forests and Endangered Species
sean.cosgrove@sierraclub.org
202-547-1141

Background

Proponents of this salvage logging plan claim that they need to expedite logging projects to prevent the wasting of valuable trees, which have been burned or blown down in a storm, and help these sensitive areas recover more quickly after a disturbance. However, scientific research does not support those claims. Logging a burned area is extremely damaging to a forest ecosystems because it compacts fragile soils, damages fish habitat and degrades water quality in streams by creating sediment run off, spreads invasive and noxious weeds, and removes live trees as well as dead and downed trees, which are essential to the ecological recovery of a disturbed area. The financial cost is also too high as taxpayers end up subsidizing timber sales that don't re-coup the amount that the Forest Service spent planning them.

Congress and the Forest Service should focus instead on protecting American’s homes and communities from fire and promoting real ecological restoration. Forest Service research clearly shows that the best way to protect homes and communities is responsible fuels reduction projects within the 500 meter Community Protection Zone. No community should be left at risk while the Bush administration and the Forest Service waste money and time on unnecessary salvage logging projects.


Up to Top


HOME | Email Signup | About Us | Contact Us | Terms of Use | © 2008 Sierra Club