Sierra Club Home Page   Environmental Update   My Backyard
chapter button
Explore, enjoy and protect the planet
Click here to visit the Member Center.         
Search
Take Action
Get Outdoors
Join or Give
Inside Sierra Club
Press Room
Politics & Issues
Sierra Magazine
Sierra Club Books
Apparel and Other Merchandise
Contact Us

Join the Sierra ClubWhy become a member? Explore, Enjoy and Protect

at risk in New Mexico
  • Mercury
  • Oil and Gas
  • Otera Mesa
  • Factsheet
  • New Mexico Main

  •  
  • More Communities
  • 2002 Report
  • Communities at Risk: New Mexico
    Mercury Pollution Makes Fish Harder To Swallow

    Bush administration delays reducing mercury emissions from power plants

    Oscar
    Oscar Simpson, president of New Mexico Wildlife Federation, used to spend a lot of time catching fish with his friends and family in Navajo Lake, which today is threatened by mercury contamination. The Bush administration's plan calls for more mercury to be spewed from stacks like those of the San Juan Generating station in northwest New Mexico, than enforcement of current laws would allow.
    For Oscar Simpson, fishing was a central point of interaction with his friends. Almost every other weekend a large group of friends and their families would go to Navajo Lake in northwest New Mexico to fish and enjoy an old fashion fish-fry. "We used to have a lot of fun and camaraderie on those fishing trips," Oscar reminisces. Today, however, much of the fun of fishing with friends is gone because the fish are contaminated with mercury, leading many of Oscar's friends to sell their boats and quit going to the lake. Mercury is released into the air when coal is burned. It then falls back to earth and into our lakes and streams, where it accumulates in the bodies of the fish we eat. Because the state of New Mexico has two of the dirtiest power plants in the nation-the San Juan Generating Station and the Four Corners Power Plant-it is no surprise that many of New Mexico's waters are polluted. According to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), in 1999 each of these two power plants released more than 1,000 pounds of mercury into our environment.1 Currently, New Mexico has the highest level of mercury emissions in the western U.S., and proposed plans from the Bush administration are not expected to clean up the state's contamination problem.2

    Mercury is a poison that causes birth defects and learning disabilities in children, and central nervous system damage in adults. Young babies, children, pregnant women, women of child-bearing age, and populations that consume large quantities of fish are at the greatest risk of mercury poisoning. The EPA recently estimated that as many as one in six U.S. women already has unsafe levels of mercury in her body, leaving approximately 630,000 newborns at risk each year.

    Power plants are the greatest releasers of mercury in the United States, emitting 96,000 pounds of mercury each year.3 The Bush administration's mercury plan would allow three times more poisonous mercury pollution than strong enforcement of current clean air laws, and for decades longer-a delay that will leave New Mexico's communities at risk from mercury pollution for years to come. We can do better. Strong enforcement of the Clean Air Act, existing and emerging technology could reduce mercury emissions by 90 percent of current levels by 2008.4

    Noting the damaging health effects, it made sense that in March 2004, the Bush administration warned Americans to limit the amount of fish we eat and feed our kids. It also makes sense that 44 states have fish consumption advisories for at least some of their waters due to mercury contamination. What doesn't make sense is that the administration's mercury proposal gives power plants permission to spew even more mercury into our air-mercury that will eventually end up in our lakes and streams and in the bodies of fish.

    In total, New Mexico has 22 warnings on the books advising us not to eat the fish from our state's lakes, streams, and reservoirs.5 Using a chart based on species of fish and the size at which they are commonly caught, the state advises pregnant women to eat no more than one meal of fish per month, even of the smallest fish. The state also advises that no one should eat the largest fish of any species found in New Mexican waters.6

    The first fish consumption advisory for mercury in New Mexico was developed for Elephant Butte Reservoir in the late 1970s. Since then, consumption advisories have been issued for 31 waterbodies.7

    Anglers spent more than $170 million dollars on fishing expenses in New Mexico in 2001, more than was spent by hunters.8 Oscar Simpson says that, "at Navajo Lake, fishing is the primary sporting activity and exceeds hunting three to one." Oscar believes that not being able to eat the fish caught in the lake is one of the biggest reasons angling families are making fewer trips there. For longtime fishermen like Oscar, mercury contamination has become the number one hindrance to pursuing this favored pastime, and it threatens to end long-running traditions of fishing at the lake for many families. Oscar knows the potential for protecting New Mexico's much-loved lakes and streams is there. But the Bush administration needs to make the health of New Mexico's residents a priority, not just increased corporate profits.

    For more information contact:
    Sarah Lundstrum, Sierra Club
    Sarah.Lundstrum@sierraclub.org
    (505) 243-7767

    Surface Water Quality Bureau
    New Mexico Environment Department
    www.nmenv.state.nm.us
    (505) 827-2470

    Western Clean Energy Campaign www.westernresourceadvocates.org/energy.html
    (303) 440-7517


    1. Clean Air Task Force, Environmental Release Profile, Air Releases for 2000.
    2. Rubel, Walter, "Area Leads in Mercury Emissions," Farmington Daily Times, 31 March 2004.
    3. EPA Factsheet Basic Information. www.epa.gov/air/clearskies/basic.html#emissions
    4. EPA, December 4, 2001 presentation to Edison Electric Institute, and EPA "Clear Skies" Summary Document.
    5. New Mexico Environment Department.
    6. Fish Consumption Guidelines Due to Mercury Contamination.
    7. New Mexico Environment Department, Surface Water Quality Bureau. A White Paper on Mercury. September 19, 2001.
    8. U.S. Department of the Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service and U.S. Department of Commerce, U.S. Census Bureau. 2001 National Survey of Fishing, Hunting, and Wildlife-Associated Recreation. www.census.gov/prod/2003pubs/01fhw/fhw01-nm.pdf.

    Photo courtesy Oscar Simpson; used with permission.

    Up to Top


    HOME | Email Signup | About Us | Contact Us | Terms of Use | © 2008 Sierra Club